St. Augustine, the nation's oldest city, is renowned for its rich history, stunning architecture, and vibrant culture. Yet, this historic gem also offers an exceptional culinary scene. Whether you're a local foodie or a visitor eager to indulge, the dining options here are sure to impress. From seafood shacks to fine dining establishments, these top 10 must-try restaurants will give you a taste of the best that St. Augustine has to offer. Let’s dive into this flavorful journey and discover the best restaurants in St. Augustine.

1. The Floridian

A true representation of Southern charm with a modern twist, The Floridian focuses on fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Their menu is brimming with dishes that are both comforting and innovative, offering vegetarian and gluten-free options alongside Southern staples like shrimp and grits. This restaurant embraces the essence of the city while catering to all palates.

2. Collage Restaurant

If you're in search of an upscale dining experience, look no further than Collage. Nestled in the heart of historic St. Augustine, this elegant eatery offers a romantic ambiance and an internationally inspired-menu. The chef's creativity shines through in every dish, making it a top contender for the best restaurant in St. Augustine for fine dining.

3. Catch 27

Seafood lovers rejoice! Catch 27 is the go-to spot for fresh, locally caught seafood. Every dish is prepared with care and attention to detail, from oysters to shrimp and the daily catch. The coastal vibes and rustic charm of the restaurant enhance the overall experience.

4. Llama Restaurant

For a taste of Peru in St. Augustine, Llama is a hidden treasure. This small but mighty restaurant delivers authentic Peruvian cuisine with a modern twist. Ceviche, lomo saltado, and homemade desserts will leave you raving about this unique culinary gem. With its exotic flavors and intimate atmosphere, Llama is quickly gaining a reputation as one of the best restaurants in St. Augustine.

5. The Ice Plant

Housed in a restored 1920s ice plant, this restaurant offers an experience like no other. Known for its farm-to-table approach and craft cocktails, The Ice Plant features a menu that rotates seasonally, focusing on the freshest ingredients. The industrial-chic atmosphere and artisanal drinks make it a must-visit spot for anyone exploring the St. Augustine food scene.

6. A1A Ale Works

With breathtaking views of Matanzas Bay, A1A Ale Works is the perfect spot to relax and enjoy delicious food paired with locally brewed beer. Their menu features a blend of Floridian and Caribbean-inspired dishes. Whether you’re craving a burger, seafood, or a refreshing ale, this place has something for everyone.

7. Preserved Restaurant

Located in the historic Lincolnville neighborhood, Preserved is an homage to Southern fine dining. The ambiance, with its charming front porch and elegant dining rooms, sets

the stage for an unforgettable meal. Preserved focuses on traditional Southern dishes with a contemporary flair, using locally sourced and sustainably raised ingredients. If you’re seeking a sophisticated dining experience, this is undoubtedly one of the best restaurants in St. Augustine.

8. Raintree Restaurant

Housed in a beautifully restored 19th-century home, Raintree Restaurant blends history with fine dining. Known for its international cuisine and variety of dessert crepes, this restaurant offers a diverse menu with something for everyone. The enchanting atmosphere and beautifully landscaped gardens make it a great place for a romantic dinner or special occasion.

9. Michael's Tasting Room

For those who appreciate Spanish-inspired cuisine, Michael’s Tasting Room is a must-try. Offering a refined tapas menu alongside an extensive wine list, this restaurant delivers bold flavors in an intimate setting. The menu features a rotating selection of small plates, perfect for sharing and savoring a variety of unique dishes. It’s no surprise that it’s frequently mentioned among the best restaurants in St. Augustine.

10. O'Steen's Restaurant

A local favorite for over 50 years, O'Steen's is a no-frills, down-home restaurant that specializes in fried shrimp. The seafood is fresh, the service is friendly, and the portions are generous. It may not be fancy, but O'Steen's is beloved by locals and visitors alike for its authentic, casual dining experience.

Conclusion

St. Augustine’s dining scene is as diverse and historic as the city itself. Whether you’re seeking fine dining, casual eats, or something in between, the best restaurants in St. Augustine offer something for every taste. From fresh seafood to Southern-inspired dishes, this ancient city is a food lover’s paradise. Be sure to explore these culinary gems and experience the unique flavors that make St. Augustine a top destination for foodies.